| |
|---|
| |
| Chapter 5 : Three Bridges to 21st Century Discipline Unique Activity : Choosing Bridges - The Great Debate! |
| Establish three teams of equal size to compare and debate the value of William Glasser, Thomas Gordon, and Alfie Kohn's work. Individuals will investigate and develop arguments to defend one of the "three bridges." Even if you do not believe in the approach, please "act as though you do" by examining the strengths and giving your best arguments. You can also examine weaknesses of the other two models to enhance your arguments for the debate. The textbook and the Web Links for this chapter can get you started with the investigations and reflections. Share what you learn with others on your team in order to prepare your best team defense of the model. Each individual in the team will be given one minute to orally defend the position, alternating among the three teams.
The debate can be done face-to-face or through distance learning, using a Voice over the Internet Protocol (VoIP) such as Centra or Skype. To use VoIP you will need a computer headset with microphone available for under $20. To use the free service of Skype, go to http://www.skype.com/products/skypeout/ and download the software following instructions on the Web site. Practice using Skype before conducting the debate. Choose someone to facilitate the debate and someone to be the timer, giving everyone an equal amount of time to defend the model. Talk about how to keep the pace moving. Be sure every voice in the whole class or group is heard. After the debate, talk with your team for a few minutes (face-to-face or using VoIP) about what you learned (strengths and limitations) about each of the three models from the points made in the debate. Why are these models considered to be "bridges to twenty-first century discipline?" Which "bridges" (ideas from these models) would you choose now based on what you learned from this task? Individually use the Personal System of Classroom Discipline template (See Link on Homepage) to reflect and write ideas you want to remember and use in your own personal system of discipline. |
| (To respond and save, please copy and paste questions and/or activities to a word processing document) |