WHY IS WATER BLUE?
Reproduced from J. Chem. Edu., 1993, 70(8), 612
Charles L. Braun and Sergei N. Smirnov
Department of Chemistry
Dartmouth College, Hanover, NH 03755
Alternative link at Dartmouth
Over the years, we have often asked scientific colleagues why it is that water is blue. Common responses have included light scattering -- after all the sky is blue -- and coloration by dissolved impurities - Cu2+ has been a popular suggestion. However, the work described below demonstrates that water has an intrinsic color, and that this color has a unique origin. This intrinsic color is easy to see, and has been seen by the authors in the Caribbean and Mediterranean Seas and in Colorado mountain lakes. Because the absorption which gives water its color is in the red end of the visible spectrum, one sees blue, the complementary color of red, when observing light that has passed through several meters of water. This color of water can also be seen in snow and ice as an intense blue color scattered back from deep holes in fresh snow. Blue to bluegreen hues are also scattered back when light deeply penetrates frozen waterfalls and glaciers.
Water owes its intrinsic blueness to selective absorption in the red part of its visible spectrum. The absorbed photons promote transitions to high overtone and combination states of the nuclear motions of the molecule, i.e. to highly excited vibrations. To our knowledge the intrinsic blueness of water is the only example from nature in which color originates from vibrational transitions. Other materials owe their colors to the interaction of visible light with the electrons of the substances. Their colors may originate from resonant interactions between photons and matter such as absorption, emission, and selective reflection or from non-resonant processes such as Rayleigh scattering, interference, diffraction, or refraction, but in each case, the photons interact primarily or exclusively with electrons. The details of the mechanism by which water is vibrationally colored will be discussed in the paragraphs which follow.
observation of the vibrational transitions that give water its
color requires only simple equipment. Figure 1 gives the visible
and near IR spectrum of H2O at room temperature
recorded using a Perkin Elmer Lambda 9 Spectrophotometer and a 10
cm quartz cell filled with "nanopure" water from an ion
exchange apparatus manufactured by Barnstead. Lower purity,
distilled water gave an almost identical spectrum. The absorption
below 700 nm in wavelength contributes to the color of water.
This absorption consists of the short wavelength tail of a band
centered at 760 nm and two weaker bands at 660 and 605 nm. The
vibrational origin of this visible absorption of H2O
is demonstrated in Figure 1 by the spectrum of D2O
recorded in the same 10 cm cell. D2O is colorless
because all of its corresponding vibrational transitions are
shifted to lower energy by the increase in isotope mass. For
example the H2O band at 760 nm is shifted to
approximately 1000 nm in D2O (See Fig. 1).
Figure 1. The upper spectrum is that for liquid H2O in a 10 cm cell at room temperature; the lower spectrum is for D2O under the same conditions. No cell was used in the reference beam of the spectrophotometer so that the "baseline" absorbance of approximately 0.04 originates in cell reflections.
The blue color of
water may be easily seen with the naked eye by looking through a
long tube filled with purified water. We used a 3 m long by 4 cm
diameter length of aluminum tubing with a Plexiglass window
epoxied to one end of the tube. Ten or more observers each
reported seeing a blue color when they looked through the tube
and observed a sunlight-illuminated white paper placed below the
vertically-suspended tube .
This observation is in accord with the spectrum of H2O
recorded in Fig. 1. For example, from the measured absorbance at
660 nm, the calculated transmission of a 3 m water-filled tube is
44% -- a loss of red intensity that should be perceptible. Light
transmitted through the empty cell was white. The large tube
volume and a limited budget precluded checking to see if light
transmitted through a D2O filled tube was indeed
white, as expected.
Water is unique
among the molecules of nature in its high concentration of OH
bonds and in its plentiful supply. Most important, the OH
symmetric (v1) and antisymmetric (v3)
vibrational stretching fundamentals are at high enough energy
[3650 cm-1 and 3755 cm-1, respectively] (1)
so that a four quantum overtone transition (v1+
3v3) occurs at 14,318.77 cm-1 (698
nm), just at the red edge of the visible spectrum. As we shall
see, these gas phase transition energies are all shifted to lower
energy by the hydrogen bonding of liquid water.
absorption strength of the successive overtone transitions of
water falls by a factor of 10 to 20 as the number of stretching
quanta increases by unity (2), overtone transitions with
more than five stretching quanta do not significantly contribute
to the color of water. Of course if the OH stretch were perfectly
harmonic, the strength of all overtones and combination bands
would be zero. Thus it is critical both that the OH potential is
anharmonic and that the fundamental stretching frequencies are
high enough that overtones with only four and five stretching
quanta can contribute to absorption intensity in the visible. D2O
is colorless, at least for path lengths on the order of meters,
because a minimum of 6 stretching quanta would be required for
any transition in the visible region.
a is Ref. 1; b
is Ref. 3; c is Ref. 2; s =
All liquid phase assignments of gas phase transitions which lie above 10,613 cm-1 are based on Fig. 1 and are speculative.
It is interesting
to compare the gas phase spectrum of water, for which all
overtone and combination bands are assigned, with the liquid
phase spectrum which appears to be less completely described with
respect to the origin of infrared and visible vibrational bands.
This is important in that it clarifies the role of hydrogen
bonding in the liquid phase spectrum, a matter of some confusion
in the several sources that address the question of why water is
Note in Table 1 that the liquid phase OH stretching band centered at about 3400 cm- 1 (3) is red-shifted from the gas phase values of v1 and v3 by several hundred wavenumbers. This shift is primarily the result of hydrogen bonding in the liquid. The shift to lower energy induced by hydrogen bonding is seen perhaps most clearly in a comparison of the stretching frequencies observed for monomeric and dimeric water in a solid nitrogen matrix. Tursi and Nixon (4 ) confirmed earlier matrix isolation work by Van Thiel et. al. (5) to establish that, while the monomer OH stretching bands v1 and v3 were slightly red shifted (ca. 25 cm-1) from gas phase energies by the matrix, the frequency of the dimer OH stretch involved in a hydrogen bond was red shifted to 3547 cm- 1. That is 105 and 209 cm-1 below the gas phase values of v1 and v3, respectively. Hydrogen bonding shifts the overtone and combination band transitions to lower energy as well (see Table 1). In fact, each of the near-IR bands of liquid water shifts to higher energy as the temperature is raised (6). This has been attributed by several workers (6, 7) to the decreasing importance of hydrogen bonding with increasing temperature. As expected from such arguments the near IR absorption bands of ice are the most red-shifted of all (6).
The assignment in
Table 1 of the four liquid phase bands from 5000 to 11000 cm-
1 seems almost certain and agrees with that of Nassau (8)
and of Luck (6). We are convinced of the assignments by
the work of Luck (6) in which the near IR absorptions were
observed in water at temperatures up to the critical point. As
the temperature is increased, hydrogen bonding decreases in
importance to the point that at 375 oC the liquid peaks are only
an average of 80 cm-1 below the gas phase transitions
of Table 1. Our assignment in Table 1 of the higher energy liquid
phase transitions from 600 to 800 nm is speculative and should
not be taken too seriously. The main point is to show that the
red absorption which gives rise to the blue color of liquid water
can be plausibly ascribed to high energy vibrational overtone and
combination bands which, like the other bands of Table 1, have
been shifted to lower energy by hydrogen bonding. We have also
measured H2O spectra like those of Fig.1 at 1oC and
at 51oC. As the temperature is lowered, the band near 760 nm
shifts to lower energy but also broadens enough to slightly
increase the intensity near 700 nm. However, the changes are
small enough that the color of water should not vary
significantly with temperature between 0 and 50 oC.
We are not the first to call attention to the vibrational origin of water's blue color. However, Nassau, in his generally excellent book (8), The Physics and Chemistry of Color, credits hydrogen bonding in water with strengthening the bonding and thus raising the frequency of high overtone and combination bands. Such frequency increases would shift H2O monomer (gas phase) transitions from the near IR into the visible thus increasing the visible absorption of water. However, as we see from Table 1, hydrogen bonding causes the stretching frequencies of H2O to shift to lower, not higher frequencies. Atkins too invokes hydrogen bonding as crucial to the visible color of water and ice (9). Instead, it appears to us that the hypothetical liquid without any hydrogen bonds would still be colored, perhaps even more intensely than is actual water. Dera too invokes vibrational overtones as the origin of the red absorption by water; his work is notable for its thorough compilation of visible spectra of water. (10) Happily, the absorption coefficients that he tabulates for water sampled from around the globe show that the absorption seen in Figure 1 is characteristic of most oceans -- pollution has not altered the color of the earth's great seas. (10)
Still one may
well ask, Why when one looks at a body of water, not through
it, does one often see a blue color? Bohren (11) has
written delightfully on the answer to that question in his book, Clouds
in a Glass of Beer, which is highly recommended. He makes it
clear that any simple answer is bound to mislead. It turns out
that contributions to the observed color are made both by
reflected skylight and by the intrinsic absorption of water
described above (11). Light scattering by suspended matter
is required in order that the blue light produced by water's
absorption can return to the surface and be observed. Such
scattering can also shift the spectrum of the emerging photons
toward the green, a color often seen when water laden with
suspended particles is observed. Furthermore, as Bohren shows (11),
the relative contribution of reflected skylight and the light
scattered back from the depths is strongly dependent on
The absorption spectrum of ice (6, 12) is similar to that of the liquid except that hydrogen bonding causes all peaks to shift to lower energy. An elegant description of the colors transmitted by snow and ice has also been given by Bohren (13). His paper should be consulted for the fascinating story of how multiple scattering combined with red light absorption in snow gives rise to a "vivid blueness" beneath snow's surface that exceeds in purity "that of the bluest sky". Bohren also discusses (13) how the larger grain sizes of bubbly ice allow deep penetration of incident light and a reflected hue that can vary from blue-green to blue depending on the color of the surface which underlies the ice.
Students are usually fascinated by the topic of color. Because the mechanism is unique, the story of the vibrational origin of the color of water and ice should attract their curious minds.
Acknowledgements Grant DE-5G02-86ER13592 from the office of Basic Energy Sciences, United States Department of Energy provided partial support of this work. Helpful comments from many of our colleagues are gratefully acknowledged. Professor Craig F. Bohren of The Pennsylvania State University provided a particularly helpful critique of an earlier manuscript.
1. Herzberg, G. Infrared and Raman Spectra; D. Van Nostrand: Princeton, 1945; p. 281.
2. Curcio, J. A.; Petty, C. C. J. Opt. Soc. Am. 1951, 41, 302.
3. Marechal, Y. Hydrogen-Bonded Liquids; Dore J. C.; Teixeira, J. Eds.; NATO ASI Series, Vol. 329, 1989, p.237.
4. Tursi, A. J., Nixon, E. R. J. Chem. Phys. 1970, 52,1521.
5. Van Thiel, M.; Becker, E. D.; Pimentel, G. C. J. Chem. Phys. 1957, 27, 486.
6. Luck, W. A. P. Ber. Bunsenges. Physik. Chem. 1965,69,626.
7. Thomas, M. R.; Scheraga, H. A.; Schrier, E. E.; J. Phys. Chem.1965, 69, 3722; Buijs, K.; Choppin, G. R. J. Chem. Phys.1963, 39, 2035.
8. Nassau, K. The Physics and Chemistry of Color Wiley-Interscience: New York,1983; pp.71-74.
9. Atkins, P. W. Molecules Scientific American Library: New York, 1987, p. 24.
10. Dera, J. Marine Physics Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1992, p.155 ff.
11. Bohren, Craig F. Clouds in a Glass of Beer, Wiley: New York, 1987; pp155-170.
12. Grenfell, T. C.; Perovich, D. K. J. Geophys. Res. 1981, 86,7447; Warren, S. G. Appl. Optics 1984,,1206.
13. Bohren, C. F. J. Opt. Soc. Am. 1983,73,1646.
Here are the images illustrating the two 1.5" ID aluminum pipes
filled with D2O and H2O hanging down from
the balcony of the Fairchild Tower at Dartmouth College.
Side view (left)
View from the bottom (right).
The image for Figure 2 was also taken from the bottom but at a closer distance.